Wednesday, July 2, 2008

On-line collaboration experiment

Last week I posted a question on LinkedIn and received a significant amount of responses. My reason for posting the question was threefold:




  1. I was curious about the answers I would receive


  2. I wanted to see the quantity and quality of responses it would generate; and


  3. I wanted to test the medium to see if it was a useful online collaboration platform for brainstorming


Well, I received a large amount of replies to my question (17 in two days). The questions are open for a week so I expect they will continue to trickle in from this point on. I asked the respondents to each provide their top three points so that means I generated a rather lengthy list of 51 points in very little time and effort. Many of the points were the same or similar, so after removing duplicates, the list was narrowed down to 38, which can also be an indicator of the quality of the responses given that some themes are definitely recurring and there don't seem to be any out in left field. So far so good. But now what to do with this rather long list? The best thing would be to find a way to get participants to vote or rank the points in order to come up with an ordered or prioritized list (we often use multivoting techniques in projects, so if this could be done online, it could be a real project team timesaver...). So there is something missing in this regard. To compensate, I have posted the list in Google Docs. This will permit collaborators to vote on the issues from the brainstormed list and then a prioritized list can be generated. The trick is to get the collaborators to participate...



So here is the question : What are the Top 10 issues facing small and/or medium sized businesses today?


The brainstormed list and results of the voting can be found below or in an easier to read format at: http://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=pcnLN5HtUKspp2c6Fq9Z2Zw






Lessons learned:

I had a bit of difficulty making the multivoting clear to all participants so it neccessitated a bit of email correspondence to clarify - my bad. Make sure the instructions don't leave any room for interpretation. Try to Poka Yoke with a couple of people before publishing the questionnaire at large.

The Google Docs method neccessitated I go into the document every time someone voted so that I could hide their results from view of the others. You don't want to influence votes by leaving it visible. This was a bit of a pain and would probably cause problems if several people try to access the document at the same time. There are probably better technologies out that that you don't have to pay for.

I made the multi-voting simple by asking for a ranking their top 10 rather than going for points. It is more intuitive for the voters this way. However, in order to come up with a final list, I had to turn those rankings into points to avoid misrepresenting the value of those criteria that didn't make the Top 10 chosen by the voters. Consequently, I could have but in a formula to automatically do this but I chose to do it directly in Excel instead - it was just easier that way. Anyway, the point is that there was another intervention required on the "facilitator"s part to do this. To be truly lean, this would have to be done automatically as the rankings are entered by the voters.

Conclusions:

I think this is a promising alternative for disparate teams to move projects ahead. I am sure there are simpler methods out there but this one worked and with a honed effort, it could become quite effective. If you have any suggestions on other ways to collaborate online, I look forward to hearing about them.


Cheers,


Patrick