Friday, May 25, 2007

Project failure survey

I have seen alot of statistics on project failures (up to 70%!). I have also seen alot of reasons given for project failures, but I have not come across any statistical data on the distribution of those reasons. So, in an attempt to try and be a bit more data driven on this subject, I would ask that you provide me with your feedback and we'll see what it gives.

Here is the question:

In your experience, please rate the percentage of project failures that can be attributed to the reasons below (the total does not have to add up to 100%, of course) :



  • Ineffective or lack of change management (people side of change)

  • Poor scope control

  • Schedule overruns

  • Cost overruns

  • Deliverable did not meet expectations

  • Other (please specify)


Sample answer: Suppose I have been involved directly or indirectly in 8 projects that I woul classify as failures. 4 had ineffective change (50%), 1 had poor scope control (13%), 6 had schedule overruns (75%), 4 had cost overruns (50%), 2 did not meet expectations (25%), and 1 was abandoned (13%).

____________________________


Here are the survey results....

of 15 respondents :

a. 73.3% cited Ineffective or lack of change management (people side of change) as a cause of project failures.

b. 80% cited Poor scope control

c. 80% cited Schedule overruns

d. 53.5% cited Cost overruns

e. 73.3% cited Deliverable did not meet expectations

f. 86.7% cited Other causes as well

Interesting to note that most feel that cost overruns are not really a cause but rather a consequence of some other cause.

Also interesting is that the Other causes can be grouped into two main categories; poor project management (or manager), and sponsorship (or lack thereof).

The affinity for each of these causes is as follows:

Poor PM includes unrealistic planning, poor manager, lack of participation, lack of acceptance of roles and responsibilities, poor business knowledge, bad communications, poor documentation, lack of discipline, bad PM approach.

Poor sponsorship includes unclear requirements, unrealistic expectations, project abandoned, change of heart or direction of project, management change, lack of support.

As for the distribution of results, it gives something like this:

Percentage of project failures attributed to:

51% - Poor PM

41% - Poor change management (people side)

32% - Schedule overruns

30% - Cost overruns

28% - Poor scope control

20% - Poor sponsorship

17% - Deliverable not meeting expectations

Thanks again to all those who participated. Hope this in informative for you.

1 comment:

Unknown said...

OK, so here are the survey results (sorry I haven't figured out how to post graphs on this blog yet...).

of 15 respondents -

a. 73.3% cited Ineffective or lack of change management (people side of change)as a cause of project failures.
b. 80% cited Poor scope control
c. 80% cited Schedule overruns
d. 53.5% cited Cost overruns
e. 73.3% cited Deliverable did not meet expectations
f. 86.7% cited Other causes as well

Interesting to note that most feel that cost overruns are not really a cause but rather a consequence of some other cause.

Also interesting is that the Other causes can be grouped into two main categories; poor project management (or manager), and sponsorship (or lack thereof).

The affinity for each of these causes is as follows:

Poor PM includes unrealistic planning, poor manager, lack of participation, lack of acceptance of roles and responsibilities, poor business knowledge, bad communications, poor documentation, lack of discipline, bad PM approach.

Poor sponsorship includes unclear requirements, unrealistic expectations, project abandoned, change of heart or direction of project, management change, lack of support.

As for the distribution of results, it gives something like this:

Percentage of project failures attributed to:

51% - Poor PM
41% - Poor change management (people side)
32% - Schedule overruns
30% - Cost overruns
28% - Poor scope control
20% - Poor sponsorship
17% - Deliverable not meeting expectations

Thanks again to all those who participated. Hope this in informative for you.